Saturday, September 15, 2007

The Non-profit defense

Saying for the day-Absolute justice is achieved by the suppression of all contradiction: therefore it destroys freedom. Albert Camus

When I was still in Crystal Falls the police ran some kind of sting operation and caught five people selling drugs. I am sure that in every small town you can find somebody selling drugs. But that wasn’t what caught my attention. One of the men argued in court that he shouldn’t be charged because he had failed to make any money at it. He was a poor seller of drugs. He had gone into the business to make money. He failed. So that should be penalty enough. I call this the bad capitalist defense.
Now if it worked and I didn’t follow the case it would have set a precedent where the bad capitalist defense could be used in other cases.
I could see the following court case.
A woman has been shot. The man who shot her is in court. He is asked for his plea.
Killer– Not guilty by reason of non profit your Honor.
Judge– You did shoot this woman.
Killer– Right in the head. A good clean shot. I do good work.
Judge. Then why aren’t you guilty?
Killer– Because her husband never paid me. He promised after the shooting to give me $50,000 but he reneged. No profit . No crime.
Judge– The husband hired you to kill his wife.
Killer– Right. But he didn’t pay up.
Judge– Didn’t you get some up front money ?
Killer– Yep. He gave me $10,000 . But I spent all of that on doing the job.
Judge– What expenses did you have ?
Killer– I had to buy a gun that couldn’t be traced. Had to rent a car in another town and drive here. Do you know what gas costs per gallon? I had to rent a motel room so I could watch his wife for awhile. It all adds up. My accountant has prepared a full expense sheet for you.
Judge – It does look like you didn’t make anything. But I have some good news for you. We took the husband to civil court and the husband was ordered to pay you $40,000. I have the check here for you.
Killer– Thank you judge.
Judge– Now , since you have no defense. I find you guilty of murder and sentence you to life in prison and a $30,000 fine.
Killer– Why $30,000?
Judge– That way you still make a profit.
Life can be exciting.

@@@@ News from Pigeon Falls-The little town in my basement where the trains still run, dragons fly, and it’s getting colder.– It snowed this morning in Pigeon Falls, a big , heavy, white snow. The ground was covered for fifteen miles around the town. This is an early snow even for a UP town.
Petrovich says it fits the prophecy. The deer are gone, the pigeons are gone. It is cold . And now everything is white. They would do well to study the driblets and look for a way out. There is always a way out.
Eino says they have had snow in September before. It happens. In a day or so it will melt and it won’t come again until Christmas.
Other people are not so sure and a lot of people are going to Petrovich’s website and reading driblets sixty two and seventy seven. They are looking for that way out.
Despite the bad coffee in Nancy’s absence and despite the fact that Nellie is not a good listener people are stopping into Nancy’s Coffee shop and sharing their ideas over a cup of coffee and a mediocre saffron bun. A number of them think that when Nancy gets back she should sing the Pigeon Falls song. Then the pigeons will come back and the snow will go. Others think that Vicky East should write a new song and sing it. Then the pigeons will return and everything will return to normal. The wildest idea is that the Governor should come and sing the Pigeon Falls song. She is a woman with power.
Will the snow continue. Is Eino right? Is Eino wrong? Should the Governor sing? Will the Governor sing? Will the poor dragon freeze? And of course is Tommy UK really the Undertaker’s kid?
Tomorrow not one of these questions will be answered but come and visit anyway.

Today's Link-Creative Musings- A depressing bit of poetry.
Another good day. In the morning I started the impossible task of cleaning off the kitchen desk. Betty painted fence. Pennie cut grass. Then Peter and his children stopped in. They went to some event. I waited for a man to come and pick up the bed I sold on the internet. Peter returned and the man came. He also took the stuff I had on free cycle. So I sold some and gave some away. Then we went out to eat. When we came back we played two games of canasta with Betty and I winning both of them. Now I need a breathing treatment.


Blogger goldennib said...

You have a very devious mind.

5:38 AM  
Blogger Margaret said...

Very devious. Selling drugs does take some smarts. Too many thugs think they can just drop out of HS and suddenly become rich. They need to know math, metric conversions of grams vs. ounces. Many science facts and even a bit of botany.

If Wisconsin has similar Medical Marijuana laws like Oregon, California or Nevada that "I didn't make any money" defense may actually hold. They can grow it, they can use it and they can distribute it - but cannot profit off of it.

6:45 AM  
Blogger Janvangogh said...

I suppose if Nancy has a good honeymoon, she might be in the mood to sing. Cant hurt to try.

6:52 AM  
Blogger Cindy said...

"but I didn't..." where have we heard that defense before?

9:13 AM  
Blogger Stacy said...

If we wait long enough, we will probably see that defence work.

11:24 AM  
Blogger Nea said...

Very funny, but I think there are lawyers who would actually try this one, they have tried everything else.... and It ranks right up there with the insanity plee..haha....because to me anyone who kills another person is insane.......

12:05 PM  
Blogger QUASAR9 said...

Funny world we live in.

States subsidise the health industry from taxes
There are a thousand charities and fundraisers for medical research

Yet when they discover a new drug, new tratment, new therapy or new surgery ... I don't see anyone rushing out to make it readily avaiable.

On the other hand it seems the law provides for these people not to make available these drugs and surgery ... unless it's for high profit.

It's these the Judges should be sending to jail:
were you subsidised from taxes?
did you receive funds from charity?

Then how dare you refuse treatment to a patient. The only thing missing from Medical Ethics is Ethics and the ethos of the whole thing.

Of course we shouldn't prosecute surgeons for murder because a patient dies ... but we should prosecute doctors & surgeons for fraud. They ask for funds and charity for medical research promising future miracle cures, and yet when they do find them, they think of 1001 reasons why not to make it readily available for patients who need it.

3:48 PM  
Blogger QUASAR9 said...

But hey, these are the same people (priests of medicine who sell cures) that Christ claimed had usurped the seats in holy places.

3:49 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is infuriating but funny how criminals try to get off these days!

Thanks for the prizes. Binker loves the finger puppets and pens. I won't let him play with the pens though. A few hours before receiving your package he drew on our white eygptian cotton sheets in ink!

4:41 PM  
Anonymous quilly said...

Mimi -- saturate the sheets in hair spray and then wash them -- unless you've already run those sheets through the dryer.

"Yes, Your Honor, I stole the car, but I shouldn't be convicted. In less then twenty minutes the car ran out of gas and I had to hike three miles on the interstate! I could have been killed! In fact, I believe I should be suing the car owner for negligence and reckless endangerment!"

11:33 PM  

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home